Every year near Reformation Sunday we celebrate this Sunday, All Saints Sunday. Martin Luther, in the 15th century, nailed his 95 theses on the door of Wittenberg Cathedral. This was how you got something discussed. In this university community which was always considering new ideas, and novel approaches, supposedly, you nailed new ideas, or papers to the door of the church. This got you a hearing.
Martin Luther nailed up his 95 theses and started a firestorm of conversation, gossip and discussion about the church.
Sometimes I think we ought to have a way to do that, discuss things, I mean. If there were some public square where we could as a church discuss the church and our faith openly. A suggestion box is a poor substitute for honest and frank discussion.
Once a friend of mine served as associate pastor. He and the Senior Pastor asked members of the congregation to answer a survey. The main question was: what is your greatest dream for your church? They got two responses from the church. One was about my friend. It said: “Ask the associate pastor to quit smoking.” I don’t remember the other response.
My friend was depressed for weeks. They had expected dreams and visions for the church and the only thing members of the church could say was “make the associate quit smoking.” Well, that’s good advice for anyone. But, where is the great debate about the church and our faith?
You might say that that great debate is always going on. We Methodists who have open hearts and minds and doors sort of believe that there is something here worth fighting and arguing about.
A number of times in the Gospels, Jesus catches the disciples arguing. They argue about which disciple is greatest. They argue about children in church, about who will be left and right of Jesus in the kingdom. They argue about passing the peace or communion by intinction. They argue, that’s for sure. But, where is the great debate over things that really matter, the truths of our faith? Where can we talk openly, discuss freely without fear?
The possibility of meaningful discussion in the public square is passing. The culture moves more and more toward an enlightenment view of the world. The enlightenment taught us that you can talk out in the open about anything you want except religion because religion causes wars and rumors of wars. And, if you can just get people to quit talking about religion and ultimately the Christian God or Jesus, then we will be able to live in relative peace.
And, we do bear some responsibility for our part in any religious wars and violence. Our history is mixed. We Christians do take up arms against others. We have hurt and wounded in the name of God.
Much of the war and violence in the world was done by Christians who started thinking that it was alright to use weapons of violence against others.
So, we reason that if we can just keep people from getting too heated over religion then we won’t have war. So we have this uneasy truce with our culture. We can say all we want to say about God or faith or religion as long as we do it in here. But, you can’t say it in school, or on the street, or at work, or at play; religion is a private matter. Just keep it private and everything will be well.
You just can’t have people who believe things deeply running around all over the place.
It is a judgement on us that we are seen as people who are more mean and cruel than anybody else.
But, what if there were a place where we could discuss the faith openly without fear.
Sunday School was like that for me. I will never forget Ms. Gladys. Gladys taught the high school class in our church for years. One Sunday, it was in the on the tailend of the turbulent sixties. She said: “Jesus was a radical.” I got upset. How dare anyone call Jesus a radical. So, I reacted, got angry. She smiled. Another guy said that saying Jesus was a radical meant that Jesus was radically different form the people around him. Of course, she was right. Jesus was a radical. But she didn’t know then that I was growing up to be a preacher.
We have to make room for honest, frank discussion about our faith. Where did we get the notion that we all have to be alike. Surely, there are some basics of faith. That’s why we say the Apostles’ Creed every Sunday to call us back to the truths of our faith, but…isn’t it possible to find a way to talk openly about our faith?
Blessings!
Dave Nichols
